Like Île du Diable, Alcatraz is an isolated island defined entirely by its prison history, where visitors must follow controlled access via timed ferry tickets. Both places exist primarily as dark tourism sites where the harsh island setting amplified the psychological impact of imprisonment. The windswept isolation and preserved prison structures create the same sobering atmosphere of confinement surrounded by unforgiving waters.

Both islands served as maximum-security political prisons using isolation as punishment, where the surrounding ocean made escape impossible. Robben Island shares the same structure of mandatory boat access and guided tours through preserved prison facilities. The experience centers on understanding how the harsh island environment was deliberately used to break prisoners' spirits, with former inmates often serving as guides.

Norfolk Island shares the legacy of being a feared penal colony where geographic isolation intensified punishment. Like Île du Diable, it was chosen specifically for its remoteness and harsh conditions. Visitors today navigate limited flight access to explore preserved convict sites and learn about the brutal history of transportation and imprisonment in this beautiful but historically dark Pacific setting.

The Solovetsky Islands transformed from monastery to one of the Soviet Union's first major prison camps, using Arctic isolation as a tool of punishment and control. Like Île du Diable, visitors must arrange boat or plane access to reach this remote location where preserved structures tell stories of suffering in isolation. The harsh northern climate and limited access season create the same sense of entering a place where geography itself was weaponized.

Goli Otok was Yugoslavia's equivalent to Île du Diable—a deliberately chosen barren island where political prisoners faced harsh conditions and complete isolation from society. Both locations used their stark, treeless landscapes and surrounding waters as psychological torture devices. Today, visitors must arrange special boat access to explore the abandoned prison complex and experience the desolate atmosphere that made these islands synonymous with political repression.